Choosing the right selective herbicide for plantain and other broadleaf weeds helps protect your turf while targeting unwanted weeds. This guide reviews trusted options that offer broad leaf weed control with turfgrass tolerance, suitable for residential and commercial lawns. Each product below is evaluated for selectivity, application timing, and weed spectrum to help you pick the right fit for your lawn’s needs.
A quick summary table of selected products:
| Product | Brand | Key Weeds Targeted | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nufarm Change Up | Nufarm | Plantain, dandelion, oxalis, thistles, other broadleaf weeds | Premium selective; wide turf tolerance |
| Atticus Torocity Herbicide | Atticus | Clover, dandelion, oxalis, crabgrass, ground ivy | Pre- and post-emergent activity |
| Nufarm Horsepower | Nufarm | Broadleaf weeds; general turf safety | Selective 32 oz format |
| Surge Broadleaf Herbicide for Turf | APS | Plantain, dandelion, clover, oxalis, ground ivy, more | Post-emergent broadleaf control |
| Quali-Pro 2-D Herbicide | Quali-Pro | Plantain, dandelion, clover, chickweed, oxalis | Broadleaf weed control in turf |
Nufarm Change Up – Premium Selective Herbicide

Nufarm Change Up is positioned as a premium selective herbicide designed to control more than 200 broadleaf weeds while maintaining turfgrass tolerance. Its label coverage includes cool- and warm-season grasses like bermudagrass, Kentucky bluegrass, fescue, and St. Augustinegrass, making it suitable for a wide range of lawns. The product is particularly noted for attacking plantain, dandelion, oxalis, chickweed, and thistles with broad turf safety. For residential and commercial lawns alike, Change Up offers flexibility in weed management without harming established turf when used as directed. Care should be taken to follow label rates and tank-mix guidelines to maximize selectivity and reduce risk to ornamentals or new seedlings.
Application timing and rate should align with weed growth stage and local climate. While it targets a broad spectrum, users should monitor for any signs of turf stress in sensitive cultivars and adjust spray intervals accordingly. As with any herbicide, wearing protective gear and following label instructions ensures safe handling and effective results.
Atticus Torocity Herbicide (8oz) – Mesotrione-Based

Torocity from Atticus uses mesotrione as its active ingredient to deliver broad-spectrum weed suppression in lawns and turf grasses. The product is highlighted for its flexibility, offering pre- and post-emergent activity which broadens the timing window for weed control. This dual-action approach helps stop new weeds and reduce existing populations, including common turf intruders like crabgrass, ground ivy, clover, oxalis, and dandelion. The 8-ounce formulation makes it a manageable option for homeowners tackling partial lawn renovations or spot treatments. Users should follow label directions closely to maximize turf safety and weed control effectiveness, particularly during reseeding or overseeding projects.
Because mesotrione is the cornerstone, Torocity has a strong track record in both established turf and newly seeded areas. It’s essential to observe local restrictions on certain turfgrass species and weather conditions to optimize results and avoid potential phytotoxicity on sensitive varieties.
Nufarm Horsepower Selective Herbicide

Horsepower is another Nufarm option designed for selective weed control in turf and lawns. The 32-ounce bottle format emphasizes convenience and coverage for larger areas while maintaining selectivity to avoid injury to most common turfgrasses. The product listing notes EPA registration and regional sale restrictions, reflecting regulatory considerations for certain states. For best results, apply under appropriate weather conditions and according to label directions. Horsepower is positioned for homeowners and professional turf managers seeking reliable broadleaf weed control without compromising turf health.
As with any selective herbicide, planning around existing turf types and weed pressure is crucial. Consider whether you need post-emergent control primarily or if you anticipate future germination that would benefit from a pre-emergent plan. Always confirm compatibility with your specific turf species and recent overseeding or fertilization schedules.
Surge Broadleaf Herbicide For Turf

Surge Broadleaf Herbicide is a post-emergent option designed for turf environments, with a wide range of target pests listed on the product label, including plantain, dandelion, clover, oxalis, and many other common broadleaf species. The formulation is suitable for residential and commercial lawns, golf courses, sod farms, schools, and other turf surfaces. It emphasizes post-emergent efficacy, enabling rapid control of existing weeds, which can be advantageous for lawns with established weed problems. For best outcomes, apply under appropriate weather conditions and avoid plant stress periods such as extreme heat or drought.
Users should be mindful of the regional restrictions cited by the label—California and New York are among zones where this product’s distribution is restricted. Always verify local regulatory guidance and follow label directions to ensure safe and legal use in your area.
Solitare Herbicide 1# – Selective

Solitare is described as a selective herbicide with a broad weed spectrum for turf applications, including plantain, dandelion, clover, chickweed, oxalis, and more. The product’s 1-pound package targets athletic fields, sod farms, golf course fairways, and other non-crop turf sites, making it suitable for professional lawn maintenance programs. As a turf-focused selective option, it aims to balance effective weed control with minimal turf injury. Always consult the label for recommended rates, tank-mix possibilities, and any restrictions on specific turf species or use sites.
When evaluating Solitare, consider the weed spectrum in your lawn and the history of past herbicide use to minimize resistance development. Pairing with a robust cultural program—appropriate mowing height, proper irrigation, and aeration—can help maintain long-term turf resilience while managing plantain and other target weeds.
Buying Guide: Key Purchase Considerations and Comparisons
- Weed spectrum and selectivity: Choose an herbicide labeled to control plantain and other broadleaf weeds while preserving the turfgrass you have. Review the weed list on the label to ensure your target species are covered.
- Active ingredient and mode of action: Mesotrione-based products offer pre- and post-emergent control benefits, while others provide post-emergent-only action. Consider resistance management by rotating active ingredients over seasons.
- Turf compatibility: Verify that the product is labeled for your turf species (cool-season vs warm-season grasses). Some products carry restrictions for specific grasses or environmental conditions that affect safety and efficacy.
- Application timing: Pre- versus post-emergent timing affects when you can apply. Pre- emergent control weeds before germination, while post-emergents target actively growing weeds. Some products provide both windows for flexibility.
- Season and climate considerations: Weather, soil moisture, and recent fertilization can influence outcomes. Avoid applying during extreme heat, drought stress, or when rain is imminent unless labeled otherwise.
- Regulatory restrictions: Note any state-specific sales restrictions or registrations. Some products restrict use in states like California or New York, or require adherence to local regulations.
- Usage scope: Most products target residential and commercial lawns, with some also suitable for golf courses, sod farms, or schools. Confirm your site type aligns with the label.
- Application safety: Always use appropriate personal protective equipment, follow handling instructions, and keep children and pets away from treated areas until safe.
- Tank-mix options: If you plan to mix with other products, ensure compatibility as described on the label or via manufacturer guidance to avoid phytotoxicity or reduced efficacy.
In choosing the best selective herbicide for plantain, consider your lawn type, weed pressure, and maintenance goals. The options listed provide a range of timing, coverage, and turf compatibility to help you build an effective weed management plan that protects your turf while targeting plantain and other problem weeds.